Maggie's FarmWe are a commune of inquiring, skeptical, politically centrist, capitalist, anglophile, traditionalist New England Yankee humans, humanoids, and animals with many interests beyond and above politics. Each of us has had a high-school education (or GED), but all had ADD so didn't pay attention very well, especially the dogs. Each one of us does "try my best to be just like I am," and none of us enjoys working for others, including for Maggie, from whom we receive neither a nickel nor a dime. Freedom from nags, cranks, government, do-gooders, control-freaks and idiots is all that we ask for. |
Our Recent Essays Behind the Front Page
Categories
QuicksearchLinks
Blog Administration |
Wednesday, April 21. 2010'House MD': A couple o' treats
Note: These videos are designed to be played in full-screen mode. Click on the little symbol on the player's tool bar to pop them open. If you don't see the little symbol, update your Flash. The keyboard's left and right arrow keys act as an 'instant replay' and 'quick forward'; the up and down arrow keys control the volume. My 'House Tribute' is here. Just for fun, I thought I'd post that clever 'speed dating' scene from earlier this season:
— For starters, you have to admit that you just don't see this kind of special effects on your average medical TV drama. A few kidneys, sure. The occasional esophagus, fine. Intersteller gas ball barreling through a supernova, not so much. — I'm letting it run past the super-duper graphics part because it opens up one of the most interesting debates around; the odds of our being alone in the universe, and leads to my own post on the subject. But we'll get to that. Remember, full-screen size:
I can relate. I felt exactly the same way after the kid's stupid remark. But as to the professor's question; is our solar system unique? Well, no. Not in the slightest. A sprinkling of inner solid planets, a few gas giants further out, a couple of ice balls on the rim, a dead zone where a planet used to be, a sun in the center, lots of empty space outside — that's all standard fare as solar systems go. Now, I certainly don't have any kind of formal training or education in the field, but if li'l ol' me can figure out the above and blow his "unique solar system" theory to smithereens, then pretty much anyone could, right? Therefore, the obvious conclusion is that he's full of beans and, as such famed astronomers as Carl Sagan have claimed, with umpteen gazillion galaxies out there, then — by the numbers alone — there must be a whole pisspot full of advanced civilizations kickin' around. Right? Except there's one little problem: That was just the professor's lame-ass theory. If Sagan and his ilk want to play the numbers game, then let's play.
Posted by Dr. Mercury
in Our Essays, The Culture, "Culture," Pop Culture and Recreation
at
13:00
| Comments (14)
| Trackback (1)
Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
Ah, well. I've had a re-interest in it lately and have rewatched most of this season over the last number of nights. As displayed in the dating clip, the show certainly hasn't lost its fun edge, and House remains as House-like as ever.
Best guess says "5 to 9" (the one through Cuddy's eyes) gets an Emmy nomination. It really stood out, like "Locked In" did last year. And it was cool letting her solve the big mystery last week in "Lockdown", rather than you-know-who. My opinion is that the show hasn't lost a step. Sorry, Doc, but I watched (IIRC) the first episode and found the non-stop insults and snarkery, and preposterous medical conditions, unbearable. I like a good, biting, well-timed sarcastic insult as much as the next guy but it needs to be given a rest - not good food for a steady diet. Real people would be knocking one another's teeth out after a work week of that sort of behavior.
Knucks - A good point, but I suppose it's a matter of "amount". Bird Dog and I only watch two shows a week, 'House' and 'NCIS'. So we're only getting an hour of the biting stuff, and that's it until next week.
Oddly enough, it's the opposite with 'NCIS', because now the hero's some guy who mumbles ten words a week and whose attempts at sarcasm would register a "1" on the House Scale. Funny how they balance out. Anyway, it's all about the amount. Given measured doses, 'House' is a great show, with some very perceptive writing at times. Thanks for the link. Its been a few years since I've watched and still see Wooster in Dr. House. great actor. Time to look the show up again.
I for one enjoy the show but if you can’t stomach the insults and snarky attitude or the unbelievable medical emergencies there is always the philosophical aspect. Almost every show delves into questions like life after death, the meaning of life, is it ethical to kill a genocidal dictator, etc.
Thanks for pointing out the Sherlock Holmes connection. Did anyone besides me think that the Robert Downey Holmes was too much like House? Scott -
"is it ethical to kill a genocidal dictator?" And, for what it's worth, they're still discussing it. I paraphrase, but from the last episode: Chase to Cameron: Hey, you wanted to do it. Cameron: Yes, but I didn't. Is it unethical or immoral to off a genocidal dictator when you have the chance? Would it be immoral if you didn't? As to your question about Robert Downey, that's very interesting. I hadn't planned on watching it (if a Sherlock movie doesn't have Basil Rathbone in it, it's not a Sherlock movie), but I just shoved it to the top of my Netflix queue. I'll get back to ya on it. We love the show and never miss it. I'm sure we've seen every episode more than once.
About the search for intelligent life in the Universe, I'm skeptical of arguments based on probability when we know so little about the causation factors we're supposed to be evaluating -- certainly too little to be able to assign them the numerical percentage values that are necessary to conduct a probability analysis. Tex99 -
I'm eternally enamored with the first seven weeks of season 4. Every now and then I get the bug and watch them over a 2-night span. Then, of course, I have to watch the last two episodes of the season and cry into my beer for the rest of the evening. Re: intelligent life elsewhere, I agree with your analysis. Just because there are zillions of worlds out there doesn't necessarily mean some kind of "probability factor" applies, like "someone will die in a car accident today." And when you throw in the billion-to-one events that kept happening to us over and over and over again, whatever "probablity factor" exists starts getting whittled down pretty fast. And here's something else to consider: I heard in some space DVD a while back that it's estimated that with our longest-range radio telescopes, we've penetrated approximately 15% of the universe. So it actually could be that we're in the "weirdo" section of the universe where these strange physical and chemical laws apply that don't apply anywhere else. The reason we've never been visited by aliens is because they're simply too embarrassed to be caught in that area, often referred to as "the seedy side of the universe." "Nutsville" is the general term in use, and any space pilot with a shred of self-respect avoids it like the plague. Which, in cultural terms, it is. I had to look up Season 4 -- that was the one with the elimination rounds for the new team, culminating in the two-part episode with the bus crash and House's amnesia. Great stuff.
I think my favorite may have been House's guest lecture, where he takes a roomful of students through three case histories involving leg traumas, and we get some backstory about his own leg. I also loved the early episodes involving the private detective who ultimately paired up with Cuddy. I'm disappointed that he rarely appears anymore and is generally wasted when he does appear. Re life and evolution: One of the things that often disappoints me about science fiction is the casual assumptions about the form that alien life is likely to take. I find it difficult to imagine how DNA evolved (though it's easy to imagine how life evolved once it had DNA), so I don't see why we should assume that other planets would produce DNA or anything like it. It is really such a natural and inevitable progression from primordial soup to amino acids to DNA? Do we understand how that happened well enough to guess whether it's likely to happen again on any planet with similar conditions, or whether it was a wild fluke? Is it likely that on another planet some other chemical basis will develop that supports the process of evolution? Texie -
The guest lecture episode, "Three Stories", would definitely be in my top five. Also "Locked In" from last season (the guy who couldn't speak) and the one in season four where both the crippled guy and his dog died. (If I ever did a "House exposé", one of the things I'd do would be to exonerate poor 13 from the blame everybody cast on her after that episode. Watch it again and you realize it was actually Kutner and Taub barging into the room and taking over the diagnosis that caused the pills to be mislaid and both the guy and his dog to die. Tsk-tsk, David Shore.) "the casual assumptions about the form that alien life is likely to take." Oh, pshaw! "Casual assumptions"? I can assure you, my dear Texas rose, that the writers base all of their characters on pure scientific evidence. For example, the last science fiction book I read, around 1970, by Larry Pournelle, as I recall, took place on the moon Titan, and the inhabitants of this beautiful world were horses galloping about -- with penises growing out of their foreheads. I shit you not. That was about the time I switched to action novels. I just love a good submarine story. Not a forehead penis in sight. As to the DNA, I really should include that in the post, but I don't know enough about it to frame the "billion-to-one" value correctly. Is it a billion-to-one that DNA on another planet would come anywhere close to our DNA, or is it a billion-to-one that, should "life" suddenly appear in the planetary cauldron, it be "DNA" to begin with? Could it be RQP or XYZ, or is "DNA" considered the 'universal law' of all life forms? House is the highlight of the television week. Audio runs through our stereo system so we mute the TV, in order to read the script and not miss any subtle nuance - or medical terms.
Linda - Now how about that for "World's Worst Job":
"Subtitle writer for a medical show" (cringe) It's fun when the cast talks about the medical terms in their interviews. They all remember their first jawbreaker line, and I think it was Morrison who summed it up by calling it something like "an exercise in phonetic memory". I'm sure the initial tryouts for the parts weren't much fun. "Okay, Ms. Morrison, just read from the sample script and we'll let you know later how you did. I'll take Dr. House's role. Ready?" "All right." "Well, Cameron, what's your take on our patient's grave condition?" "Gosh, Dr. House, with those swollen eyelids and pink toenails, I think he's got pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis!" "You're hired!" As with all good actors, it's all in the delivery. Scott, if by any miracle you actually subscribed to the thread, you were absolutely 100% correct in your assessment of the Robert Downey 'Sherlock Holmes" connection. There were a couple of scenes when he was buffaloing poor Watson that had "House/Wilson" written all over them.
And it was a fun movie in other ways. I wasn't overly thrilled with the bad guy, but the "fight preview" scenes were really cool. And I liked that he played Holmes as kind of a tough badass. Great suggestion, and thanks for mentioning it. |
Here. A few comments: 1. Watch that Speed Dating video2. Don't get the wrong idea from the comments - Merc and I do not watch this show together - it just turns out we both watch it3. House's character is Sherlock Holmes (get it? House - Holmes). Holmes,
Tracked: Apr 22, 07:08
Newer ones get added to the bottom. The Deafening Silence — My favorite 'airline disaster' episode Men & Women of Film — A Hollywood collage Train Story with a Twist(er) — Kids! RC Madness — Three R/C airplane vids Happy Guy Fawkes Day — Ho
Tracked: Jul 10, 07:10
Newer ones get added to the bottom. The Deafening Silence — My favorite 'airline disaster' episode Men & Women of Film — A Hollywood collage Train Story with a Twist(er) — Kids! RC Madness — Three R/C airplane vids Happy Guy Fawkes Day — How this
Tracked: Aug 04, 16:22
Newer ones get added to the bottom. The Deafening Silence — My favorite 'airline disaster' episode Men & Women of Film — A Hollywood collage Train Story with a Twist(er) — Kids! RC Madness — Three R/C airplane vids Happy Guy Fawkes Day — How this
Tracked: Aug 04, 16:56
Newer ones get added to the bottom. The Deafening Silence — My favorite 'airline disaster' episode Men & Women of Film — A Hollywood collage Train Story with a Twist(er) — Kids! RC Madness — Three R/C airplane vids Happy Guy Fawkes Day — How
Tracked: Aug 28, 15:39