We are a commune of inquiring, skeptical, politically centrist, capitalist, anglophile, traditionalist New England Yankee humans, humanoids, and animals with many interests beyond and above politics. Each of us has had a high-school education (or GED), but all had ADD so didn't pay attention very well, especially the dogs. Each one of us does "try my best to be just like I am," and none of us enjoys working for others, including for Maggie, from whom we receive neither a nickel nor a dime. Freedom from nags, cranks, government, do-gooders, control-freaks and idiots is all that we ask for.
Our Recent Essays Behind the Front Page
Thursday, August 8. 2013
I recently stumbled on this story. It's very old, and it seems to be well known in Math and Engineering circles. I shared it with my team to give them some idea how to work together and be open to unusual and creative ideas.
Long ago, there was a wealthy man who had 3 sons. Among his most prized posessions were 17 camels. The man was renowned as being very shrewd. In his will, he determined that his oldest son should get 1/2 of his estate(whatever he owned at the time of death), while his second born son should inherit 1/3 of his estate. His youngest son, being the yougest should inherit 1/9 of his estate.
After the father died, the three brothers were quite happy to inherit that wealth. They loved and respected their father very much so they were quite eager to satisfy the will of their father exactly. However, they did not like the idea of killing some of the camels in order to honor the last will of their father:
1/2 of 17 camels makes 8 and 1/2 of a camel figured the oldest brother, 1/3 of 17 camels makes 5 and 2/3 of a camel calculated the second brother, 1/9 of 17 camels makes only 1 and 8/9 camels thought the youngest brother.
A dead camel was not worth much, so it made perfect sense that they hesitated to proceed with the execution of the will. How could have our father made such a mistake in his will? He must have been very bad at arithmetic, they thought. They asked their friends for advice, but nobody really knew what to do in this case. Finally, somebody recommended that they sit with a well known old philosopher. He had solved many difficult problems for the populace, and eager to solve their problem, they followed this advice, bringing their camels to see the old man. The philosopher offered them some tea and listened to their story.
"I agree, this is a difficult problem and I do not know what to do. But please come back tomorrow morning, perhaps I will have an idea overnight".
The next morning they came back and found the old man already expecting them. Says he: "This was indeed a very difficult problem, and I had to think all the night long before I saw how to solve it. Before solving your problem, let me make you a gift. I am very much impressed by your eagerness to honor the will of your father, so I will give you in addition to the 17 camels you already own one more camel out of my own possession."
The three brothers were now very excited, they got a free camel, which was more than they expected with this visit.
"OK," said the old man. "Now let's now try to execute the will of your father. You, the oldest son, how much are you supposed to get?"
"One half of 18 camels," says the oldest son. The philosopher handed the reins of 9 camels to the eldest.
"And you, second son, how much are you supposed to get?"
"1/3, which would be 6 camels," the second son replied. The philosopher handed him the reins to 6 camels.
Finally, he turns to the youngest son and asks him: "How many camels do you get?"
"Well sir," answers the third brother, "I am supposed to get 1/9 of 18 camels which makes precisely 2 camels."
The three brothers take their camels away and discover to their surprise that there is one camel left. (9+6+2 = 17 but there were 18 camels).
"This camel", says the old man, "happens to be my own camel and, although I gave it to you as a present, I will now take it back as a fee for the service I performed by solving the problem".
The three brothers were extremely pleased. No camel had to be killed, and yet the will of their father was completely satified. Full of admiration for the wisdom of the old men, they thanked him many times and left back home. Going over the miraculous solution on the way home, they realized their father must have known arithmetic
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)
"Three sons and a Camel". After that lead in, the actual joke was a disappointment ;)
Which reminds me of the old joke about the brand new 2LT in the French Foreign Legion. The punch line of which is: But Lieutenant, the men ride the camel to the brothel in town!
Of course, the father's intention could have been to see if the sons would have the wisdom to seek advice when presented with a dilemma.
That was part of my take on the story. How do you provide an inheritance while teaching a lesson at the same time?
My intent, in telling the story to my team, is to help them realize they are not the only ones who have the answers, and they certainly do not know everything they need to know. Nor do I. But to find a way to work together will often yield interesting and unusual solutions that make many people happy.
Bulldog, if I were 60 years younger I would apply to work for you, no matter what you do, as long as it's mostly legal.
Yeah, like anyone on your team will ever have to divide 17 camels among 3 people. They must think you're batty.
Camel BBQ today. Yum.
Bear Grylls is taking the hide for some other purposes that I'd probably prefer not to know about.
Of course, the sons soon started arguing over who actually paid the fee of one camel.
The younger soon will soon be claiming he paid 90 percent of the fee, while the oldest son will be saying he paid almost half of the fee. Each will soon begin bribing the son to agree with their argument to get ready for the death of their mother, who also owns 17 camels.
Anyone who understands common denominators or is a more creative than literal thinker would probably yawn over this story, but it might amaze people here to see how much of America would find this story a revelation. In managing a business I see people everyday who need lessons like this.
I'm sure my young plebes will get something from it.
I also believe it's a story about working together to find a solution, though. As well as one about respecting knowledge and experience.
Whoever drafted Dad's will forgot to specify who was supposed to get the remainder of the estate (17/18 of a camel) after the brothers all got their full shares, which didn't add up to 100% but only to 16-1/18 out of 17:
= 17/9 + 17/3 + 17/2
= 1-8/9 + 5-2/3 + 8-1/2
= 1-16/18 + 5-12/18 + 8-9/18
= 14 + 37/18
= 14 + 2 + 1/18
Although the will didn't call for it, the brothers awarded themselves a "wise man's" fee in the total amount of 17/18 of a camel, and allocated it among themselves in shares proportionate to their 1/2-1/3-1/9 split. That's how they each managed to round up to a whole number of camels. All the wise man did was cover a temporary liquidity problem in the amount of one camel, so as to make the arithmetic easier, then he took his loaned camel back without interest.