We are a commune of inquiring, skeptical, politically centrist, capitalist, anglophile, traditionalist New England Yankee humans, humanoids, and animals with many interests beyond and above politics. Each of us has had a high-school education (or GED), but all had ADD so didn't pay attention very well, especially the dogs. Each one of us does "try my best to be just like I am," and none of us enjoys working for others, including for Maggie, from whom we receive neither a nickel nor a dime. Freedom from nags, cranks, government, do-gooders, control-freaks and idiots is all that we ask for.
Our Recent Essays Behind the Front Page
Thursday, October 30. 2008
Cory Miller the Well-Driller's open letter to Obama
Mr. Miller is a "Joe the Plumber," the kind of American the Dems do not understand because Leftist ideology cannot account for such fine folks. His open letter to Obama is below (h/t, Eclectic Will). I know plenty of people who have done the same, and who could have written similar letters. Cindy had an email chat with Cory.
From: Cory Miller
Given the uproar about the simple question asked you by Joe the plumber, and the persecution that has been heaped on him because he dared to question you, I find myself motivated to say a few things to you myself. While Joe aspires to start a business someday, I already have started not one, but 4 businesses. But first, let me introduce myself. You can call me “Cory the well driller”. I am a 54-year-old high school graduate. I didn’t go to college like you, I was too ready to go “conquer the world” when I finished high school. 25 years ago at age 29, I started my own water well drilling business at a time when the economy here in East Texas was in a tailspin from the crash of the early 80’s oil boom. I didn’t get any help from the government, nor did I look for any. I borrowed what I could from my sister, my uncle, and even the pawnshop and managed to scrape together a homemade drill rig and a few tools to do my first job. My businesses did not start not a result of privilege. It is the result of my personal drive, personal ambition, self-discipline, self reliance, and a determination to treat my customers fairly. From the very start my business provided one other (than myself) East Texan a full time job. I couldn’t afford a backhoe the first few years (something every well drilling business had), so I and my helper had to dig the mud pits that are necessary for each and every job with hand shovels. I had to use my 10-year-old, ½-ton pickup truck for my water tank truck (normally a job for at least a 2 ton truck).
A year and a half after I started the business, I scraped together a 20% down payment to get a modest bank loan and bought a (28 year) old, worn out, slightly bigger drilling rig to allow me to drill the deeper water wells in my area. I spent the next few years drilling wells with the rig while simultaneously rebuilding it between jobs. Through these years I never knew from one month to the next if I would have any work or be able to pay the bills. I got behind on my income taxes one year, and spent the next two years paying that back (with penalty and interest) while keeping up with ongoing taxes. I got behind on my water well supply bill 2 different years (way behind the second time… $80,000.00), and spent over a year paying it back (each time) while continuing to pay for ongoing supplies C.O.D. Of course, the personal stress endured through these experiences and years is hard to measure. I do have a stent in my heart now to memorialize it all.
I spent the next 10 years developing the reputation for being the most competent and most honest water well driller in East Texas. 2 years along the way, I hired another full time employee for the drilling business so that we could provide full time water well pump service as well as the well drilling. Also, 3 years along the path, I bought a water well screen service machine from a friend, starting business # 2. 5 years later I made a business loan for $100,000.00 to build a new, higher production, computer controlled screen service machine. I had designed the machine myself, and it didn’t work out for 3 years so I had to make the loan payments without the benefit of any added income from the new machine. No government program was there to help me with the payments, or to help me sleep at night, as I lay awake wondering how I would solve my machine problems or pay my bills. Finally, after 3 years, I got the screen machine working properly, and that provided another full time job for an East Texan in the screen service business.
2 years after that, I made another business loan, this time for $250,000.00, to buy another used drilling rig and all the support equipment needed to run another, larger, drill rig. This provided another 2 full time jobs for East Texans. Again, I spent a couple of years not knowing if I had made a smart move, or a move that would bankrupt me. For the third time in 13 years, I had placed everything I owned on the line, risking everything, in order to build a business.
A couple of years into this, I came up with a bright idea for a new kind of mud pump, a fundamentally necessary pump used on water well drill rigs. I spent my entire life savings to date (just $30,000.00), building a prototype of the pump and took it to the national water well convention to show it off. Customers immediately started coming out of the woodworks to buy the pumps, but there was a problem. I had depleted my assets making the prototype, and nobody would make me a business loan to start production of the new pumps. With several deposits for pump orders in hand, and nowhere to go, I finally started applying for as many credit card as I could find and took cash withdrawals on these cards to the tune of over $150,000.00 (including modest loans from my dear sister and brother), to get this 3rd business going.
Yes, once again, I had everything hanging over the line in an effort to start another business. I had never manufactured anything, and I had to design and bring into production a complex hydraulic machine from an untested prototype to a reliable production model (in six months). How many nights I lay awake wondering if I had just made the paramount mistake of my life I cannot tell you, but there were plenty. I managed to get the pumps into production, which immediately created another 2 full time jobs in East Texas. Some of the models in the first year suffered from quality issues due to the poor workmanship of one of my key suppliers, so an employee and I (another East Texan employed) had to drive across the country to repair customers’ pumps, practically from coast to coast. I stood behind the product, and made payments to all the credit cards that had financed me (and my brother and sister). I spent the next 5 years improving and refining the product, building a reputation for the pump and the company, working to get the pump into drill rig manufacturers’ product lines, and paying back credit cards. During all this time I continued to manage a growing water well business that was now operating 3 drill rig crews, and 2 well service crews. Also, the screen service business continued to grow. No government programs were there to help me, Mr. Obama, but that’s ok, I didn’t expect any, nor did I want any. I was too busy fighting to make success happen to sit around waiting for the government to help me.
Now, we have been manufacturing the mud pumps for 7 years, my combined businesses employ 32 full time employees, and distribute $5,000,000.00 annually through the local economy. Now, just 4 months ago I borrowed $1,254,000.00, purchasing computer controlled machining equipment to start my 4th business, a production machine shop. The machine shop will serve the mud pump company so that we can better manufacture our pumps that are being shipped worldwide. Of course, the machine shop will also do work for outside companies as well. This has already produced 2 more full time jobs, and 2 more should develop out of it in the next few months. This should work out, but if it doesn’t it will be because you, and the other professional politicians like yourself, will have destroyed our country’s’ (and the world) economy with your meddling with mortgage loan programs through your liberal manipulation and intimidation of loaning institutions to make sure that unqualified borrowers could get mortgages. You see, at the very time when I couldn’t get a business loan to get my mud pumps into production, you were working with Acorn and the Community Reinvestment Act programs to make sure that unqualified borrowers could buy homes with no down payment, and even no credit or worse yet, bad credit. Even the infamous, liberal, Ninja loans (No Income, No Job or Assets). While these unqualified borrowers were enjoying unrealistically low interest rates, I was paying 22% to 24% interest on the credit cards that I had used to provide me the funds for the mud pump business that has created jobs for more East Texans. It’s funny, because after 25 years of turning almost every dime of extra money back into my businesses to grow them, it has been only in the last two years that I have finally made enough money to be able to put a little away for retirement, and now the value of that has dropped 40% because of the policies you and your ilk have perpetrated on our country.
You see, Mr. Obama, I’m the guy you intend to raise taxes on. I’m the guy who has spent 25 years toiling and sweating, fretting and fighting, stressing and risking, to build a business and get ahead. I’m the guy who has been on the very edge of bankruptcy more than a dozen times over the last 25 years, and all the while creating more and more jobs for East Texans who didn’t want to take a risk, and wouldn’t demand from themselves what I have demanded from myself. I’m the guy you characterize as “the Americans who can afford it the most” that you believe should be taxed more to provide income redistribution “to spread the wealth” to those who have never toiled, sweated, fretted, fought, stressed, or risked anything. You want to characterize me as someone who has enjoyed a life of privilege and who needs to pay a higher percentage of my income than those who have bought into your entitlement culture. I resent you, Mr. Obama, as I resent all who want to use class warfare as a tool to advance their political career. What’s worse, each year more Americans buy into your liberal entitlement culture, and turn to the government for their hope of a better life instead of themselves. Liberals are succeeding through more than 40 years of collaborative effort between the predominant liberal media, and liberal indoctrination programs in the public school systems across our land.
What is so terribly sad about this is this. America was made great by people who embraced the one-time American culture of self-reliance, self-motivation, self-determination, self-discipline, personal betterment, and hard work, risk taking. A culture built around the concept that success was in reach on every able bodied American who would strive for it. Each year that less Americans embrace that culture, we all descend together. We descend down the socialist path that has brought country after country ultimately to bitter and unremarkable states. If you and your liberal comrades in the media and school systems would spend half as much effort cultivating a culture of can-do across America as you do cultivating your entitlement culture, we could see Americans at large embracing the conviction that they can elevate themselves through personal betterment, personal achievement, and self reliance. You see, when people embrace such ideals, they act on them. When people act on such ideals, they succeed. All of America could find herself elevating instead of deteriorating. But that would eliminate the need for liberal politicians, wouldn’t it, Mr. Obama? The country would not need you if the country was convinced that problem solving was best left with individuals instead of the government. You and all your liberal comrades have got a vested interested in creating a dependent class in our country. It is the very business of liberals to create an ever-expanding dependence on government. What’s remarkable is that you, who have never produced a job in your life, are going to tax me to take more of my money and give it to people who wouldn’t need my money if they would get off their entitlement mentality asses and apply themselves at work, demand more from themselves, and quit looking to liberal politicians to raise their station in life.
You see, I know because I’ve had them work for me before. Hundreds of them over these 25 years. People who simply will not show up to work on time. People who just will not work 5 days in a week, much less, 6 days. People always looking for a way to put less effort out. People who actually tell me that they would do more if I just would first pay them more. People who take off work to sit in government offices to apply to get free government handouts (gee, I wonder how things would have turned out for them if they had spent that time earning money and pleasing their employer?). You see, all of this comes from your entitlement mentality culture.
Oh, I know you will say I am uncompassionate. Sorry, Mr. Obama, wrong again. You see, I’ve seen what the average percentage of your income has been given to charities over the years of 2000 to 2004 (ignoring the years you started running for office - can you pronounce “politically motivated”); you averaged of less than 1% annually. And your running mate, Joe Biden, averaged less than ¼% of his annual income in charitable contributions over the last 10 years. Like so many liberals, the two of you want to give to the needy, just as long as it is someone else’s money you are giving to them. I won’t say what I have given to charities over the last 25 years, but the percentage is several times more than you or Joe Biden (don’t you just hate goggle?). Tell me again how you feel my pain.
In short, Mr. Obama, your political philosophies represent everything that is wrong with our country. You represent the culture of government dependence instead of self-reliance; Entitlement mentality instead of personal achievement; Penalization of the successful to reward the unmotivated; Political correctness instead of open mindedness and open debate. If you are successful, you may preside over the final transformation of America from being the greatest and most self-reliant culture on earth, to just another country of whiners and wimps, who sit around looking to the government to solve their problems. Like all of western Europe. All countries on the decline. All countries that, because of liberal socialistic mentalities, have a little less to offer mankind every year.
God help us…
just a ordinary, extraordinary American, the way a lot of Americans used to be.
P.S. Yes, Mr. Obama, I am a real American… www.cmillerdrilling.com
Posted by Opie in Our Essays, Politics at 08:53 | Comments (57) | Trackbacks (2)
Display comments as (Linear | Threaded)
I've been looking for six months for something simple, honest and powerful enough to send around to those that just "don't get it". I think I've found it.
To the Water Well Driller,
We don’t know how much taxes he ends up paying.
In addition, he doesn’t live in a vacuum.
Without the people around him he would not be where he is.
Teachers, who gave him education, nurses, food processors and services, working people, military families, are REAL AMERICANS. They are not there for the money, and they do work as hard as he does. Unlike business people, their taxes are deducted automatically; they can’t fiddle the IRS. REAL GOD BELIEVERS are those who can see the whole picture and do not let their emotions and ideology rule their lives and others.
If it weren't for 'business people' most folks in the country wouldn't have jobs. We work hard too AND believe its' time for a change. Let's face it, Republican power is what got this country to where it is now. We can't risk more of the same. People, please open you minds, take a minute to think about how we got to this point in History. And by the way, we do respect your hard work and time served in the Armed forces, we'd hope that you can respect ours.
I've put in many a night & long hard weeks as a business person in the hospital industry, retail (I think you guys buy food from stores), and now in building product manufacturing, starting in 2000 all my jobs have been in jepordy because of things like mergers, outsourcing/offshoring and now the current economy. Just because I do my job with my brain and not my back doesn't make me less American, I was born & raised here in a small town, my work and carreer took me to the city's where I've thrived and enjoy (I never thought I would) . I got assistance to go to school, in the form of a student loan that I payed back and a Basic Grant as I was a single mom who had to leave an alcoholc husband. That $1200 grant has been paid back many times because my income IS WAY more than it would have been without that education. Seems like that handout paid off.
so you guys who call yourself Real America, I'm sorry I'm just one of those hard working non-Americans working in the business world, making and decent living which was another American dream when I started. I believe we are the mojority of the taxpayers and the ones who will benifit from Obamas plans. I dont' think we're un-real or non Americans, after all we are the majority.
To niksgrandma :
Nobody faults those that take a hand up and use it and become productive members of society. But many people have to make it on their own though because they are not black, female, or some other minority or foreigner. (btw - just what is a minority anymore?)
For all of the people that truly deserve a break, and will actually do something with it, that is what "the system" is for. It is not there for all of the people that are simply too lazy too work for it to begin with, or don't think they should have to, or why should they bother if they don't have to.
And for those who have been raised by 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th, etc. generations of welfare, give me a break.
For those that have received an opportunity to have anything better outside of welfare then do something with it, better yourself, better your children. Make a real difference.
I have known many people who have received benefits, like yourself, that truly needed them, and went on to a better life. That is truly fantastic!! The system worked!!
The sad, sad truth is that you are a minority. Most people that ask, more like demand, that everyone else makes up for them, don't ever do a thing with what they are given, except demand more.
Sure, Obama will help folks like yourself, but he will also help many many folks that should offend you because you have worked hard to advance yourself(and while paying taxes of course)but so many others will not. Please, take the blinders off.
It's not as though I think that McCain or the Republican party is really that sympathetic, or understanding of the true plight that many Americans face, but it's the fact that Obama and the Democratic party are too sympathetic.
How to raise a nation of whining snivelers (and by the way, that sure does buy an awful lot of votes, now doesn't it?)
Both parties and both candidates suck.
At this point, it's just a question of who sucks the worst.
Some people just need to get off their ass.
Sounds like you've been a worker bee. As such, you work hard, and you get paid what you agreed to be paid for that labor. Fine. Nothing wrong with that.
What Mr. Miller has done is far beyond that, and it has nothing to do with working with your back or your mind ... it has to do with taking extraordinary financial risks to grow a business. Something you apparently never did ... being content to put in your hours and get your paycheck.
Your employers never asked you to take personal liability for the debts of the business ... like Mr. Miller did, time and again. You were free to walk away and take a different job at any given time. Or change businesses at the drop of a hat (which you did).
Why should you expect high returns on your low-risk investment of time? Mr. Miller made high risk investments with his time and efforts, and he deserves to reap a proportionate return for those risks.
It IS UN-AMERICAN to expect a benefit that you didn't earn.
A friend also forwarded the letter to me, and I sent it on to Sean Hannity, who, yesterday (11/18/08) read it on the air and then called Cory Miller for an interview. I recorded the interview and posted it at http://www.brookhavenretreat.org/c_miller_on_hannity.htm.
Well said, Mr. Miller.
I will send this to everyone I know. Mr. Miller and others like him have made America great. Obama and his ilk will destroy it.
Time to get to work.
In one letter, he's told us more about himself than Obama has told us in two books.
Thanks for posting. What scares me, as it apparently does Mr Miller, is that there is a real possibility that this country will elect a Marxist, associate of known racists, communists, and terrorists, whose campaign is underwritten by thousands of illegal donations, and who benefits from illegal "voter registration" activities of "community development groups" (whatever the hell that means) and from an in-the-tank mainstream media who claim to know "what's good for us". It's a disaster waiting to happen. And it scares the absolute shit out of me that someone--who got Obama himself to admit, on camera, that he supports redistribution of wealth--is investigated and castigated in numerous ad hominem attacks by rabid leftists and, yes, the mainstream media!!! Oh, yes--Mr Kerry is talking "New Deal II"? It makes me sick that the junior senator from Illinois has even gotten this far, even if (hopefully) we elect Senator McCain.
Excellent letter, Mr Miller! I think you have voiced the sentiment of most honest, hard working people in this nation! I have a blog and I will post your letter on it! Thank you for your letter! Jim A
That was awesome! I want to go purchase a mud pump just to support this great American.
My brief research indicates that the letter is real. I sent an email to Mr. Miller to confirm it.
It's damn good.
Can you let us know if he writes back? It was almost too good, and half-way through I got that cynical shudder of reaching the end and seeing: SEND THIS TO FIVE PEOPLE!
I hate myself sometimes. No, I don't. I hate that I've been made to become so cynical. :(
Sarah Palin can relate to this guy, she's been there. None of the other candidates have a clue.
Amen! I don't see why more people can't get this concept through their heads. Are they that jealous of someone who has succeeded that they'd rather pull him down and take his money instead of working harder to raise themselves up?
What a great letter! I, too, plan on sending this to some folks that can still be 'saved'. I come from a family of risk-takers in business and well understand Mr. Miller's feelings. With Mr. Obama's policies these types of enterprises will be only a memory. Why work so hard and take such risks just to be punished with higher taxes to support the folks who wait for the government to take care of them. Something that Mr. Miller didn't mention was what has to be rigorous government intervention in his business at the state and local levels. I'll bet he's 'regulated' to the hilt!
Mr. Miller said what Mr. McCain should be saying.
[i]Mr. Miller!!![i/] Millions of prayers and blessings are going to heaven on behalf of you and yours, mine among them. My mother was born in Sweetwater, Texas, the sweetest named place on earth. You have refreshed us all, with sweet water, Mr. Miller. Keep drilling. There are tens of millions who think just like you: The Silenced Majority. The dirt on Obama and his circle of haters won't wash off with all the water in Texas. See you at the polls.
NtroP - I don't think it's only envy of success. I think it's the need to expiate shame for failure. It's something very similar to what Bernard Lewis explained about islamofascist culture in "What Went Wrong?"
That liberal media sure plays y'all like a fiddle.
I did not make a graph of the table, but a quick scan down the list suggests to me that the position of any state in the list correlates with the state's population, with small states getting back more than they pay in taxes, populous states less than they pay. Is that a surprise? I don't think so. I could be wrong, but I think that's usually true, not just between states, but also within states, regardless of blue/red leanings: rural areas usually get back more than they pay in taxes.
PS: I forgot to add that it is important to know how the figures in that table were calculated. Take, for example, New Mexico, a small state with a population of 2 million. Did the calculation of the "payback" include the budgets of the Los Alamos and Sandia national laboratories? That's highly relevant because the Los Alamos lab alone has an annual budget of over $2 billion. At least that's how much we know about. It could be quite a bit higher if we were to count additional funding for top secret projects whose budgets are aggregated but for security reasons not itemized (I believe that's called the "black budget", but I'm not sure of the terminology---someone can correct me).
It would seem that the blue/red give/take graphic is deceptive as the states in blue for the most part collect a great deal more at the state level than the red states listed. Wouldn't it be wonderful if less than a dollar was spent for every dollar collected? What a concept that is.........
This is by far the best and well written letter that I have read concerning the Obama truths. I fear for my children and their children if he wins the Election. All of the Obama Kool Aid drinkers need to read this.
There is a video out with a single Marine talking to Obama. It's about 90 seconds. As of noon today, it had eleven million hits. Tonight, Brit Hume, in talking about the power of the Internet in politics, showed part of it. It is as powerful as this letter.
Luther! Can you put up the link?
Here you go Meta. Too bad McCain couldn't have played this at the debates.
Pretty powerful stuff.
oh. I just watched it again. Makes me cry.
Well, it's gone viral so plenty of people will see it.
DEAR MR. MILLER,
PART OF THE RESPONSIBILITIES AT MY JOB IS TO GO THROUGH DAILY EMAILS. YESTERDAY I WAS DELETING MOST OF THE CONTENTS OF THE WORK MAILBOX BUT INSTEAD OF DELETING THIS EMAIL I PRINTED IT OUT AND STAPLED IT TOGETHER AND LEFT IT OUT SO WHOEVER IN THE OFFICE WANTED TO READ THE OPEN LETTER HAD THE OPPORTUNITY AVAILABLE TO THEM. MY COWORKER KASIA HANDED ME BACK THIS PRINTOUT WHICH I DID NOT READ MYSELF AND TOLD ME SHE THOUGHT IT WAS WORTH THE TIME TO READ THROUGH THE SEVEN PAGES. I BEGRUDGINLY ACCEPTED THE PAPERS AND BEGAN TO READ. I WAS COMPLETELY CAPTIVATED BY YOUR STORY AND I NEEDED TO THANK YOU FOR TAKING YOUR TIME TO WRITE SUCH A AMAZING ACCOUNT OF THE CHALLENGES AND ULTIMATE SUCCESS OF THE AMERICAN DREAM. YOU ARE CORRECT IN YOUR OPINION OF HARD WORK AND SELF-MOTIVATION BEING A KEY FACTOR IN LIFE'S DREAMS. MY HOPE IS THAT OTHERS WILL SOMEDAY REALIZE THAT UNLESS SOMETHING IS EARNED AND NOT GIVEN IT CAN NOT BE VALUED AND APPRECIATED.
Thank you for taking the time to write this letter that so graphically portrays the substance of what America stands for and who we are as a people. I have just read statements Obama made about our American flag and our national anthem. He hates our flag and our anthem because other nations hate it and our anthem speaks of war. How does he think we ever became a free nation? How can people be swayed by rhetoric that has no real substance and by someone whose mentors and friends have all be haters of the Amerian way. It's time for people to wake up!!!
You are a great American. There are many Americans just like you. I'm one of them. My name is Jay. "Jay the Printer". Like you, I can from a blue collar family. The same families that Barrack Obama claims to want to help. College was not discussed in my family and so I went to work like you. I worked for year for next to nothing and supported a wife and two children. We always made our bills somehow. I ended up getting a divorce but still managed to pay my bills and child support. I am proud to say that I did not miss a CS payment in 15 years. I worked two jobs to make this happen. Then I lucked into a sales position that finally rewarded me for my hard work. My wife and I are now considered rich. Not only do I give up 28% of my income to the federal government, I didn't get a stimulous check. Then I get slammed with the Alternative Minimum Tax payment because by 1960 standards, the government thinks I rich too. It's just not right that 5% of the top wage earners pay 85% of all taxes. We live very modestly. We try and save to put our children through college, but for what? If they become successful, then Obama and his liberal buddies will take their money too! There is no incentive to become successful anymore. Keep up the fight, brother
This was referred to me by a friend at Boeing... amazing stuff & very well said. I'm a native Californian (rare, I know), but there must be a little Texas in me, because Mr. Miller's life story struck a chord that sounds just like my grandfather's and my Dad's.
My Dad was a small contractor who was also on the giving side of 'spreading the wealth'. A hard-working, honest-as-the-day-is-long guy that made sure his workers got paid before he did. Went out of his way to use military vets. Despite this, he was ultimately forced out of business by government minority-preferenced programs that handed out over-priced contracts to unqualified, unexperienced people looking for "free money" and handouts. He tried his best, but the work came increasingly more difficult to get because he was the wrong minority... a white, small business owner.
Truth be told, we are the silent majority yet we've remained quiet too long for fear we'll be labelled as hate-mongers, racists, etc... liberal propaganda "to keep us in our places".
NO MORE! We must start fighting the good fight by voicing these positions - the pen IS mightier than the sword (that's why they so fear Joe). Stay in the face of these bureaucratic pinheads - the Joe's, Cory's and Jane's have shown us how & set the bar. Fervently support those statesmen/politicians who share conservative, fundamental small government values with your $, AND most importantly VOTE!!!
I tried to comment on this article but wasn't allowed to post.
I appreciate your grit, gut & ethics to build your business. But how you tie that to Mr Obama ruining it all is mostly an utter crock. You, along with most of the country, would still fare better under Barack Obama than John McCain. There have always, and will always, be taxes. The difference is John McCain taxes the middle class more to subsidize the wealthy. Barack Obama taxes the wealthy more to subsidize the middle class. The middle class are closer to bankruptcy than the wealthy. This being true, Obama gets my vote. I hope your business continues to do well, but not your politics.
All Good Things,
GREG... nice try.
But there always have been and will always be, poor people. The difference is that Obama will take more money from my pocket to give to those that will value it less. As I worked for mine... their's fell from heaven... or the government. Same thing, right. As Obama is the Messiah.
What a bunch of hogwash. Obama's plan rewards the majority of Americans with tax breaks, and only 5% of the highest-paid Americans will pay more in taxes. This top 5% is the group who can afford tax attorneys and CPA's to help them find loopholes to allow them to pay less in taxes, and who can take bigger tax write-offs for their businesses. I can guarantee you that Mr. Miller has taken full advantage of the tax breaks offered to small business owners, and has written off his many business losses. I fail to see how Obama is responsible for the problems Mr. Miller has faced, since it was the Republican presidency and the Republican faction in congress who allowed our economy to slide towards disaster. You can look it up -- the economy has always fared better under Democrats than under Republicans despite "conventional conservative wisdom". A vote for McCain is a vote for the failed policies of the last eight years under Bush. Are all of you really saying you want 4 more Republican years? As for the claims of Marxism and socialism, the US is already heading that way on Bush and McCain's watch -- they advocated the bailout with the federal government now holding a percentage of the banks... That is socialism! If I were Mr. Miller, I'd gladly pay a few dollars more in taxes if I knew that the economy would fare better and I'd have more business as a result. Because I'd make more money to more than offset that increase in taxes. I have been in sales -- as a small business owner -- for over 25 years, and I have always made more money under Democrats, because the economy was stronger. Under Bush, I have watched my base pay remain constant while prices increased, and my sales dipped because of the economy. I'd gladly go back to paying more in taxes if it meant that consumer confidence improved and I'd make more in sales. Is Obama the perfect candidate? Of course not. Will his election solve all our economic and financial problems? Of course not. But I cannot vote for a Republican who will continue running this country into the ground as the last one has. McCain is just like Bush, only more erratic, more volatile, and more economically uninformed. Bush effectively killed more Americans by sending them to Iraq to die than the number that were slain on 9/11. McCain would continue sending Americans to die in Iraq needlessly, and continue spending 10 billion a month in taxpayer money -- which could be used for tax credits, scholarships, small business loans, and education -- to do so. Obama is my choice. McCain is the wrong choice for America. And don't even get me started on McCain's idiotic choice for a VP. That woman is ignorant, conniving, and serves as proof that McCain is not fit to make decisions that affect all of us.
Well Eric, you sound like just the person I've been looking for to ask their advice on who to vote for in this election. Why your your attitude and perspective on Sarah Palin alone is just so precise and void of emotion as to make you seem a real genius in your parsing of the real issues and problems that face this country. Yeah boy, you sure seem to have a handle on every little facet of of what I need to know to make the correct decision of who to vote for. So... being as I disagree with everything you say... I guess my mind is made up. It'll be McCain/Palin for me.
Thanks so much for your help.
Eric, I could not have expressed this view point better then you did: you are the only person on this blog who makes sense.
Excellent. I had received this in e-mail and had looked for a site that already had it posted figuring it had gone viral. We all know a Cory and a Joe who wants to be him.
Cory Miller is perhaps the most self righteous person I've ever read. In his unquestioned mind, no one who makes less is: as hard working, patient, self-reliant, generous, takes risks or determined as he is. The rest of us are lazy or unmotivated. Every thing he has he earned and everything he didn't get is the "socicialists" fault. And what about those "needy" people that he claims to have given money to - is he a sucker for giving to the people who didn't pull themselves up by the bootstraps? And what about his own govenor Bush? Is George Bush who mismanaged almost every thing that was given to him more deserving that the many millions of self reliant, ambitious, hard working people in the country? If Cory Miller spent a little more time researching the candidates qualifications instead of listening to Rush Limbaugh, he would be a lot more optimistic. The animosity and intolerance have convinced him that everything is going to be taken away by Barrack Obama and his "ilk". That is complete nonsense. He hasn't checked it out for himself.
Let me get this straight: Cory Miller claims to be self-reliant, and hard working, having gotten what he's got through hard work, and not birthright.
But he's going to vote with the presidential candidate who was born with a silver spoon in his mouth (or at least a military career guaranteed), who graduated nearly last in his class, whose fortune came from fortuitous marriage, instead of the presidential candidate who fought his way from poverty to graduate from two Ivy League universities, and scrap his way into top positions in his own business?
Is there any logic there? I don't see it.
You can't reason a guy out of a position he didn't get to by thinking. Cory's another example of that.
This is late, but still felt like it was worth it. I guess, Ed, you believe that anyone born with a "silver spoon" in his/her mouth, isn't worth two cents. I guess because a man was given a second chance to succeed in life, that he shouldn't have his hand shaken for what he has accomplished. If you look at probably, 90% of graduating college students they most of them did not do so well in their first semester or even first year of college and most of these students would have made A's and B's in high school. It's like the old saying goes, "you can't judge a book by his cover" nor can you judge them for past failures. Take Bill Gates for example, would you fault him for filing bankruptcy a couple of times before he actually got Microsoft right, I bet you buy his software don't you? Just because someone initially was handed a "silver spoon" doesn't mean they haven't worked to get where they are in life, otherwise McCain wouldn't have run for President and made it as far as he did. I do NOT come from riches, nor have I have I had my life handed to me on a "silver platter", but I am doing well and work very hard to get what I want as I am sure most successful american's do...it is the one's who sit back and wait for their welfare check to come in the mail that tick me off. Mr. Miller actually received a letter from a man that said he was greedy and how dare him not want to share his wealth with him. I am floored that there are actually people out there expecting a hand out from someone that has worked VERY hard to obtain the things he has. I am saying this as a general statement, not just in support of what McCain did for our country. I guess some people forget who fought for our country's freedom...and rest assured, we will still fight for many years to come.
I share your fears. At the same time I think it is unlikely that Obama is going to go back to the way Dems were in the '70s and '80s. If anything he'll ultimately run into pressure to lower corporate tax rates over the longer term . I also have owned businesses and currently have 14 employees in a business that I started on credit cards.
One of the great questions you raise is why banks are so tough on business loans. Even without congressional pressure on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac it's far easier for an individual to walk in a bank and get a $300,000 mortgage than a $300,000 business loan. It suggests that banks care far more about collateral than buyer worthiness or that the algorithims haven't been invented yet to determine who's worthy and who's not.
Finally, I think Obama is better internationally by a long shot. We have to finally get an administration that deals with other people as they are and not as we want them to be.
I do see both sides of the story as this has occured in my family as well. My dad owns his own business and is doing great. Both my siblings and I hope to be on the same path someday as we are all workaholics. We are all democrats in a highly Republican state, not because of money issues though. Look at the full picture. Almost all of the people I talk to can't give a reason as to why McCain picked Palin as his VP candidate.
Yea, I don't agree with people being taxed more to 'spread the wealth'. I hear people say all the time that it is our duty and obligation to help the people in Iraq and give them a chance to be 'free.' Isn't that what Obama is trying to do in our OWN country, which is where our (should be everyone's) money going to???
I agree with someone's comment above. Both candidates suck, and there is never a way out to perfection.
You are mixed up. You must admit, you just don't like half-white man. Who went to Iraq, in the first place, to spread our taxpayers dollars?
Shmo, if you want to succeed in business, you ought to examine all the facts before making any future decisions.
Warren Buffet said that his receptionist pays a high tax percentage of her income then he does, and of course, he is on e of the richest men in world. He is a smart American!
I understand who put us there in the first place Dave. But when McCain agreed with supposedly 90% of his policies, how is that any different? I haven't heard anything different that would happen. All I constantly see is McCain going on the attack against Obama on how he will mess the country up. I don't ever hear how McCain's policies will be better.
Again, politicians like to bs and ignore questions like crazy, as I'm sure you've seen in the debates so far. They've both done it.
I'm not biased towards any news organization either, as I watch them all. To settle the tax discussion, I believe we should have a Flat Tax - straight across the board.
your posting sounds fair enough to me.
i think finding solutions to issues our country is facing, is of paramount importance. this approach is my choice, and it's the most mature.
Thank you for sending me a letter written by what many people would call an "average" American. He speaks about a number of issues pertinent to the conservative base, issues like entitlement, free enterprise, and Barack Obama's track record of facilitating bad home loans while working with corrupt community-organizing organizations. I'd like to address some of these issues from what I guess is the "liberal" point of view considering that my views oppose Mr. Miller's, but as you read my replies please try to evaluate them objectively. Perhaps there is something to them, perhaps not, but please don't discount them solely because I am a young American college student living in California.
Mr. Miller's discussion is mostly based on his opinion that Americans have become increasing dependent on their government for help (He never mentions when this trend began, only that it currently plagues us). It is probably safe to say that he is concerned specifically with the country's tendency to seek FINANCIAL support from the government, be it direct or otherwise. So then, he probably isn't a proponent of Welfare, of Food Stamps, of Medicaid, and he must certainly be no fan of programs designed to ensure that all Americans have as close to equal access to bank and home loans (financial tools he admits were vital to his business' development). All the people who are able to stay afloat (and alive in some cases) because of programs like Medicaid and Welfare would be left to their own devices in Mr. Miller's world. But nonetheless, Mr. Miller holds to his philosophical stand against all forms of "BIG" government interference because he believes there is a fundamental causal relationship between increased government support and the decline of American values: i.e. the more a government interferes into its citizens' lives, the more harm that government will inflict on the necessary values of free-enterprise and self-reliance. "Grab your Gun and get into the fight," I can imagine him saying.
OK, let's talk about this philosophical dynamic Mr. Miller has presented to us. What are these values really? How do they hold up in certain situations (like the one in which we currently find ourselves), and what do they tell us about ourselves as a people? If it is true that the presence of handouts entices our society into giving up our "American values" of self-reliance and free-enterprise, then perhaps these values aren't as strong and ubiquitous as we seem to think they are. I mean, if these two values are truly "values" in the sense that we as a people, as a country, as a government, hold them faithfully through times good and bad then we should see even those Americans reeling from the current financial crisis turn a blind eye to government support. We should see banks take responsibility for their failed policies and proudly walk out of their skyscrapers knowing that opportunity awaits them around the corner so long as they stick to their "values". We should see those who have defaulted on their mortgages living proudly in tents or RVs or whatever it is that they have left because they know their "values" will get them through this tough phase.
But the bankers aren't holding their chest high, waiting to rebuild. They are in Washington asking for help from the only entity left in the world with the capacity to help them resolve their troubles. We don't see families living proudly and defiantly with relatives in other cities, in shelters or in portable housing. We see them heartbroken, with tears in their eyes and sobs in their voices when they discover that they will no longer be living in the home where many raised a family, where their lives were defined, built. I know some of you are thinking that the banks only went under because the "liberal" wing of government made them give loans to risky borrowers. I'll address that issue more fully later. Let's stick to the discussion of American spirit for now. My point is this: While we are all Americans, we are human first. Every person faces times in their lives when they need someone to turn to, and in instances when there is no one to turn to, when your credit is ruined for whatever reason and the bank won't give you any more money, when your friends and relatives have nothing to give because they too are suffering the blows of financial turmoil, when you have lost your job to cheap labor overseas, and/or when you just aren't making enough from all the work you are producing, it is the DUTY of us all as a nation to lend a hand to those among us who have fallen on hard times. If we do not feel compelled to help our fellow CITIZENS, our brethren, our blood, then we as a people are not a nation, but a collection of individuals living amongst each other, separate and not overall concerned with our neighbor's well-being. I say if anyone is entitled to anything, it is these people who are suffering. They are ENTITLED to some care from a neighbor, a friend, their government, and best of all, a total stranger (a Samaritan you might say).
But we do not feel like helping these people who are suffering by first building a strong government who can support them. We have a tendency to look out for ourselves, just as our friend Ayn Rand would have us do. Our nation was founded on such principles of individuality, where everyone can be as they care to be. But this idea of individuality carried with it implicit ideas of community, for it seems safe to say that an individual cannot prosper without the support of a community of fellow individuals working to maintain their rights and freedoms. In order for us all to be individuals, we must be closer knit than other nations, not more divided. We cannot be rabidly individualistic and maintain a fabric of unity at the same time. We must be citizens of a nation first, and individuals living amongst each other second. The idea is "Be an individual while helping others maintain their individuality" not "Be an individual and forget to care about other individuals". An easy step toward building a strong community in which individuals can thrive is making sure that all the people in that community are capable of educating their children, of living in decent, secured housing, and of having a sure job. But before we can take steps to ensure any of these ends we must first want to be a community.
So, Mr. Miller, when you speak to others about entitlement, about the failing American values you see all around you, don't forget to mention how far we have faltered from the fundamental principles any society must rely on to makes it way in the world, don't forget to mention how we lack a sense of community that is necessary for individual growth. Moreover, Mr. Miller, I find it hard to believe that a man like yourself, who knows how hard it can be to make it in the world, wouldn't want to see people in situations like the one in which you found yourself early on assisted in some capacity. I mean, wouldn't it have been nice if you could have gotten to where you are now without having to go through as much of the hardship that you went through? Or do you wish the same hardship on all those fighting to get to where you are now? You should consider yourself a blessed man to have reached your level of accomplishment, blessed and lucky. For every one of you there are another five who cannot make it.
Please do not mistake what I say as a blatant endorsement of Socialism or anything of the sort. There is a place for competition and self-improvement in every society. We know that when these drives are removed people tend to work less. But I don't think we must make it as hard as we make it on people who want to succeed. We don't have to be in a state of total competition in order to maintain our drive of self-improvement and free enterprise. Nations like Britain and Scandinavia (as a whole) see to it that every citizen in their nations is endowed with certain rights so that they may make an easier way of it in the world They are given health care, public transportation, and other public utilities so that they will have less to worry about. We too deserve these things.
So now when we talk about entitlement, let's talk about our being entitled to reasonable health care prices, to lawmakers and government officials who are accountable for their decisions in office, to help when we are at our worst.
Finally, the Act Mr. Miller claims has been a detriment to our nation's values and which he cites as evidence of Senator Obama's poor judgment because the Senator voted to uphold it deserves to be fully disclosed. It is called the Community Reinvestment Act and it was first enacted during the Carter years as a measure to prevent banks from charging black and Hispanic borrowers higher interest rates than whites of similar socioeconomic standing. It has survived through Republican and Democratic administrations alike. Even Reagan, the godfather of modern conservatism, didn't think it fit to take it off the books.
And, Senator Obama's ties with ACORN came mostly when he defended them in a trial in the early 90's. That is ALL! He is not working for them incognito, he is not trying to take over the world, and he is not the messiah, but he IS damn smart. He did graduate from Harvard Law School and teach Law at the University of Chicago (not a shabby institution by any stretch of the imagination).
I am so serious when I say that this election is about much more than who will be president for the next four years. We are currently on the brink of some serious issues, both financial and philosophical. Many experts, including the former Comptroller General of the Government Accountability Office (essentially the nation's accountant) David Walker predict that we cannot keep in our current trend of spending. Some of you will say 'But wait, Obama wants to spend an additional 700 Billion a year' or whatever the figure is. 'Where will we get this money?' you ask. We will get it back from Iraq where we have been fighting for over four years without any sign of returning home. You will say, 'But we can't leave now, the place is a wreck'. It was already a wreck when we got there, not because of Saddam Hussein's harsh tactics, but because it is an a nation built on arbitrary beginnings (Side note: Iraq's present boundaries were the result of haphazard districting of the Middle East by European nations after the First World War. They never took the ethnic and religious demographics of the region into consideration when they created Iraq, and thus it is no wonder that a man like Saddam Hussein was welcomed to power; only a man as harsh as him could have brought relative peace to a nation divided by 3 distinct groups, two of which have been embattled in serious religious debate and war for at least 500 years). Now that they have an army of over a hundred thousand men, a legislature, and relative peace, don't you think we ought to come home? They do not want us there anymore. There was a rally held in the streets of Baghdad a couple of weeks ago protesting our presence there. We are no longer wanted there. I ask you to consider whether you are a citizen of the American nation or of the American empire, because by definition peaceful nations do not impose their military power on other nations who have not provoked war.
The evidence is in, and we as a nation have made some tremendous blunders. I'm not saying President Bush is totally to blame. He has been asked to make some of the toughest decisions of any president ever. But we are not in a good way, and we need someone like Barack Obama, a man with a solid vision, the knowledge, the demeanor, with NEW ideas, and with the will power to help us rise through this mess. We cannot be individuals right now, just like we couldn't be individuals during the last Depression that rocked this country. When you are casting your ballots tomorrow, remember that John McCain will not help the majority of Americans through this, He will impose Trickle-down economics just like Bush has, he will deregulate our economic infrastructure just like Bush has, and all these policies will fail us again, just as they fail us now. Its not that Senator McCain's ideas don't make sense: They do in fact make sense, in theory. In reality however they have failed to achieve their goals. We need something new, we need something fresh, we need Barack Obama.
Nothing personal Mr. Miller. I have great respect for your accomplishments, but not for your political philosophy. What we take to the polls in our hearts and minds reflects our morality, and I believe it is time we give those morals a thorough going over.
Make it out tomorrow if you haven't already,
-A Texan in California
You said it most eloquently. I very much appreciate your mastery of the English language and the clarity of your thoughts.
Typical college student ... pages of pointless emotional, self-serving blather with no logical conclusion. You should ask for a return of your tuition money; college isn't helping. Overeducated and undersmart.
"Need" is when you want to take someone else's property.
"Greed" is when you want to keep the property you worked for.
"Compassion" is when a politician arranges for the transfer.
Although your letter is "eloquent" as stated, it lacks the warmth and faith of wisdom. I did not vote for Mr. Obama, but I do wish him well, we as American's are counting on him.
Many of these comments are frighteningly ignorant. The respondents have not learned that they have a right to 100 percent of their income. Period.
Where do you think 100% of your income comes from? I would venture "other people". We are all in this together.
Your income comes from a freely contracted exchange ... your time, effort, and possibly product for money. Or a market derived rate of return on use of your capital by others who think they can earn a greater return due to their knowledge and expertise.
It isn't a gift given to you by "others".
We are by no means "all in this together", any more than the Army of Northern Virgina and The Army of The Potomac were all in the Civil War together.
Let's keep the meta-religious socialism psychobabble out of this. It's too easily used as rank rationalization for theft and confiscation, because one side thinks their "need" is more important or more legitimate than the actual propoerty owner's.
Just to cure any curiosities, Cory is real. I have personally known Cory for 16 years. He is a wonderful God fearing man and everything he said about his story is 100% truth. God bless!
I share your hope for a better life for everybody and a just system of government. I don't think either a "Republican" or a "Democratic" philosophy correctly represents that hope. Nor does adhering to or promoting “conservative” or “liberal” agendas.
I read the whole “Well Driller” thing Mr. Miller, and while very inspiring unfortunately the last third of it decomposed into a diatribe against "liberals". Don't lose focus on the fact that you are crying over the rollback of a questionable tax cut that only amounts to giving up a 3% tax cut in a tax bracket that never should have gotten it in the first place.
You begin your complaint section with the following very questionable point: "This should work out, but if it doesn't it will be because you [Obama], and the other professional politicians like yourself, will have destroyed our country's’ (and the world) economy with your meddling with mortgage loan programs through your liberal manipulation and intimidation of loaning institutions to make sure that unqualified borrowers could get mortgages."
I would like to know how many "conservative" heads of banking, at Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, Fanny & Freddy Mac, AIG, our Treasury Dept. and our Federal Reserve, not to mention the hundreds of thousands of mortgage loan department heads at thousands of banking institutions across the country [u]can honestly say[u/] they didn't participate in, benefit from and yes, dream up the irresponsible financial instruments that were sliced and diced and repackaged until nobody knew what their true value was any more, then fraudulently misrepresented and sold and resold to countless innocent investors globally while our “conservative” rating agencies, Moody's and Standard and Poor's maintained falsely high ratings on all these firms? I guess all these people, plus those that lobbied Congress for the benefit of the hedge funds (all of which manage, legally, to pay minimal or no taxes on their gains), plus all those involved in the credit default swap debacle, plus everybody at the SEC that allowed the Depression era price uptick stock selling law to be changed conveniently in 2007, and allowed naked shorting of stocks to continue unpunished, ALL THESE PEOPLE were "liberal" think tank types? Is that what you Mr. Miller wants us to believe? Sure sounds like it. Fortunately I am not that uninformed. I take the trouble to inform myself... Mr. Miller, you may know everything under the sun about drilling but he sounds like you need some input from people who don't fit the label of 'conservative" or "liberal". Of course, you'll have to set your ego aside first; that is the almost impossible step so many cannot find the courage to take.
It is oh so easy to be a so-called or self named "conservative" and to lash out and blame the so-called "liberals" for everything that has gone wrong in our country. It is much more difficult (and humbling) to think outside the box and get beyond these unfortunate labels. A lifetime of tying oneself to either of these self identities is part of what has polarized our dysfunctional country into an exclusively two party electorate. The saddest thing about this election is not that Obama beat the Republicans. The saddest thing is that NOT ONE third party candidate took a seat in the new Congress! Also, NOT ONE third party candidate for President managed to get even 1% of the vote.
Anyone that overly rejoices the Obama victory is blind to what makes our system of government as poorly functional as it is. Anyone that overly regrets McCain's loss commits the same mistake.
Nice story!!!! So Mr. Cory Miller you are exempt from paying taxes forever. Mr. Miller, can you tell me why my state of New York pays more money in taxes to the federal government than it gets from the government? Can you tell why Texas gets more money from the federal government than it pays to the federal government? Can you answer these questions for me? I say that we pay no taxes at all!!! I am against wealth sharing!!!!
God bless America!!
Jan.22,2011..Well, OBamas been around for the past couple
of years..now go back and read all these comments written
before the election...it should make some of you feel like
fools, if you'll look what a 'community organizer has done to
our country. This all started back when we allowed NAFTA
to destroy our working mans jobs. And who was in control
of congress during that time? Raise taxes on the rich, then
less money for investment will be around and thus no jobs,
except more government. gene
Found this over at Maggie's Farm and it is well worth the read: Cory Miller the Well-Driller's open letter to ObamaFrom: Cory MillerMr. Obama,Given the uproar about the simple question asked you by Joe the plumber, and the persecution that...
Tracked: Oct 30, 21:29
Please, please, pass this letter around. There are many people in the US like Mr. Miller. How many of you depend on people like him for your living? If so, Obama is THE LAST PERSON you want in the White House. From: Cory Miller Mr. Obama, Given the...
Tracked: Oct 31, 07:16