Maggie's FarmWe are a commune of inquiring, skeptical, politically centrist, capitalist, anglophile, traditionalist New England Yankee humans, humanoids, and animals with many interests beyond and above politics. Each of us has had a high-school education (or GED), but all had ADD so didn't pay attention very well, especially the dogs. Each one of us does "try my best to be just like I am," and none of us enjoys working for others, including for Maggie, from whom we receive neither a nickel nor a dime. Freedom from nags, cranks, government, do-gooders, control-freaks and idiots is all that we ask for. |
Our Recent Essays Behind the Front Page
Categories
QuicksearchLinks
Blog Administration |
Thursday, August 20. 2020Ageing and ExerciseAn excellent essay or, more precisely, long excerpt from the book Exercised. One quote:
Another:
Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry
No Trackbacks
Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
The information presented here is entirely correct. But for many people, especially those who are older, exercising is not easy. People have back pain, knee pain, and other problems which preclude traditional forms of cardiovascular training. One alternative to physical exercise is a cold water bath. The English used to recommend that people take a cold bath every day. Fifty degree water, for half an hour every morning. The cold water has several effects. It removes a few hundred heat calories from your body, which can lead to weight loss. And it's very stimulating. It's not a perfect replacement for exercise, but it helps. But it's not for diabetics, or people with heart problems, or small children. For a cold bath, you have to be an adult in reasonably good health.
"senescence is also influenced strongly by environmental factors like diet, physical activity, or radiation, and thus can be slowed"
I think that to some extent this is wishful thinking. Literally billions of people have aged badly who thought exactly that. Mostly because so many of these symptoms are genetic. There is a strong belief that fat people suffer more illness and die young. But in fact being skinny is a worse marker for both of those things and surprisingly a lot of 'fat' people live to an old age. Ditto for exercise. I believe in exercise but in fact many sedentary people also live to a rip old age. It is easy for someone in their 40's and 50's to think "so far so good, I must be doing something right". But in fact you need to check back when you are 75 to hear them say "it sure went to hell in a handbasket fast". Forget anything that the 20 or 30 something crowd says they are totally clueless and this includes the doctors, physical trainers and other self styled experts. Here is the only good advice for people regarding long life and good health: Don't smoke!!! Don't do drugs or abuse over the counter drugs. Don't drink or at the least seriously limit your drinking. exercise regularly and moderately. Eat based on the MDR, don't exclude an entire dietary category (like meat and dairy). Avoid all fad diets (Keto, paleo, macrobiotic, ornish, South Beach, etc.) Avoid supplements and the latest "superfood". Take a one a day type of vitamin is you wish or feel you need it. The rest is all pure BS. That's good advice. But I smoke cigarettes, and I really don't have any great desire to live to a ripe old age. I don't know why people are obsessed with making it to eighty or ninety. We have millions of barely conscious old people sitting around in wheelchairs; and I don't think that they're having a good time.
When my knees give out completely, I'm going to move peacefully into the next world. It's easy. All I need is thirty peaches. I'll break open the pits, get the soft parts inside, and then eat them. It's painless, and a hundred percent effective. Maybe I'll make a peaches and cream milkshake, just for fun. You need to do some squats and deadlifts, Ron, get those knees and back strong and healthy.
“But few of them explain why”
Doesn’t matter why. It just is. Just do it. As our elders used to say “it’s good for what ails you”. Get up off the couch and quit making excuses. As for doing squats and deadlifts as we age, there are other ways to keep your legs strong: climbing (or running) stairs, biking, body squats (especially one-leggedj, yoga, exercise programs like P90X etc. Martial arts training works your legs extremely hard, plus you would know how to defend yourself. The list is long and varied. Depends on what you like and what you need. Certainly any activity is better than no activity. But, as the linked article states (see also the work by Hans Selye), your body adapts to the stress applied to it. So by doing body weight only squats, you are adapting your legs to support your body weight, something that doesn't take even previously sedentary people very long to do. That's the value of barbell exercises, where you can incrementally increase the weight being moved and therefore continue to increase your strength for a long time, to levels well above what you could accomplish with body-weight only exercises.
Yes we get it, barbell squats are great. But not everyone can or will do them and it’s misleading to preach it as the only worthwhile exercise for avoiding decline.
It’s a battle against decline, not pursuit of the ideal. Any 80 year old that can do sets of body squats is killing it. Old folks who want to do more, go right ahead. With all due respect, Grandpa getting off the toilet on his own is not "killing it".
This gentleman is killing it: 92-year old athlete deadlifts 235 and how he got there This young-at-heart couple is killing it: Ann and Carson Look, I get it, squats and deadlifts are hard and can be scary when they get heavy (but virtually anyone without significant physical issues can do some form of those exercises). That's why people look for permission to not do them and instead stick with brisk walks around the neighborhood, body weight squats and puttering around the garden, being told that this is "good enough for health". I'm not pursuing the ideal, I'm just trying to push the idea of doing more than the absolute bare minimum to battle against the decline. It's money in the bank for when we get older. And when you find yourself picking up a weight that just a few months previous you thought was an impossibility, that's quite a feeling, and you've learned a lot about yourself on the journey to that point. I will never, ever forget the feeling I had after I deadlifted 500 lbs for the first time in competition. Do people really care about how many one-legged squats they can do? I know I'm preaching to the choir, but....
If grandpa did squats (or lunges or rucking with a heavy pack or some training that increased his strength and muscle mass) when he was younger, he would delay the onset of sarcopenia and weakness that makes getting of the crapper a chore. More often that not, it's the people with physical issues who need to be doing these movements (and then eventually doing them with added resistance). "Money in the bank"!!!!! Bingo - Yahtzee - Jackpot. If you don't put money in the bank when you're "young", there won't be anything there when you need it. RE One leg squats - don't knock them. They are a reasonable alternative for people who opt for bodyweight training (didn't you post the links to biomechanics? - the right levers can make bodyweight movement as effective as weights). They are an option when gyms are closed or when one is traveling. Probably won't allow you to break any powerlifting records, but will give grandpa ability to get off the crapper, carry in the groceries and enjoy life.
#3.1.1.1.1
mike
on
2020-08-22 22:24
(Reply)
Doing one legged squats or running stairs is real exercise, as opposed to getting off the toilet.
Believe what you like, I do not care in the least. I am more interested in improving the lives of the many people who cannot or will not do barbell squats, so I advocate for other forms of exercise that are “good enough” because for most people that’s good enough. I don’t understand what is complicated about this. A variety of choices gets more people to be more active. That’s winning. mike - I was with you up until the last paragraph. Where did the biomechanics papers I linked to imply that "the right levers can make bodyweight movement as effective as weights"? Not even sure I know what that means.
Jeff - That's got to be the worst motivational saying I've ever seen: "For most people 'good enough' is good enough." :-)
#3.1.1.1.2.1
RJP
on
2020-08-24 21:24
(Reply)
Your body responds quickly and profoundly to what you do with it — and to it — every day. This is beyond obvious for anyone who has ever started or stopped exercising, changed their diet, started or stopped medications, etc.
|