Murray's idea is far too rational to be tried, but it's a darn good mental exercise. Count me as being in favor of it. One quote:
We start with a country that is the richest country in the world, with most of its people having lots of money (compared to any historical standard), ample money to provide for their own retirements, medical care, and the rest of it. On top of this national wealth, we then add more than $1 trillion to help people provide for comfortable retirement and medical care, and so forth. And guess what? We still have millions of people without comfortable retirements, without adequate medical care. And only a government can spend that much money that ineffectually.
The alternative I suggest is give every adult American, age 21 and older, $10,000 a year. And let them run with it.
Read the whole thing - link above.